Introduction
Nowhere else in the world has there been an attack as widespread, systematic and all-encompassing on the rights of women and girls as in Afghanistan. This assessment by the United Nations reflects the severity of the Taliban's current governance. Since regaining de facto authority on 15th August, 2021, the Taliban have reinstated the Ministry for the Propagation of Virtue and the Prevention of Vice, an institution historically associated with arbitrary abuses. In August 2024, the Taliban published a 114-page document titled Laws on Vice and Virtue, codifying extensive restrictions on daily life and deepening violations of fundamental human rights.
Women's Rights Violations
Although the document affects all Afghan citizens, it has particularly severe consequences for women. Article thirteen requires women to veil their bodies in public and mandates face coverings to avoid temptation. Clothing must not be thin, tight or short. Additional provisions state that women must veil themselves in front of unrelated men, that women's voices are intimate and should not be heard singing or reading aloud in public, and that women should not look at men outside their immediate family.
These rules directly contravene the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women. Afghanistan ratified this treaty before the Taliban's resurgence, and under international law a de facto government is considered an apparatus of the state. The Taliban are therefore bound by obligations relating to freedom of movement, expression, peaceful assembly, employment, political participation, health care and education.
The codification of these restrictions formalises the Taliban's disregard for international human rights standards. It also reflects a continuation of longstanding violations that have characterised Taliban governance since the nineteen nineties.
Previous Violations of Women's Rights
The Taliban's approach to women's rights has historically involved dress code restrictions, segregated employment, limited educational access and mandatory male guardianship for travel. These measures have produced harmful consequences. United Nations reports show that hundreds of women have been denied employment, that legal mechanisms for reporting gender-based violence have collapsed, and that women have been arbitrarily arrested for dress code violations.
Despite these realities, the Taliban's supreme leader has claimed that necessary steps have been taken to provide women with a comfortable life under Sharia. United Nations experts strongly disagree, noting that the Taliban have exhausted rights relating to education, work, health, movement and freedom from discrimination. The new Vice and Virtue laws therefore represent another step in a broader pattern of systematic repression.
Attempts to Alleviate Violations
International Court of Justice
One potential avenue for accountability is the International Court of Justice's jurisdiction under the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women. This route requires another state to initiate proceedings, which can be complex and time-consuming. However, once a case is filed, Article forty-one of the ICJ Statute allows states to request provisional measures that provide temporary protection while the case is adjudicated. This could strengthen diplomatic efforts by producing a clear legal record of violations.
United Nations Intervention
The United Nations has documented extensive restrictions imposed by the Taliban, including fifty-two new decrees between June, 2023 and March, 2024. Human Rights Watch has urged the United Nations Human Rights Council to strengthen the mandate of the Special Rapporteur, establish an independent investigative mechanism and ensure continued dialogue on the situation of women and girls.
The Council has encouraged Afghanistan to uphold its treaty obligations, including rights to freedom of thought, conscience, religion, peaceful assembly and education. However, these recommendations do not constitute collective action, and meaningful alleviation requires further steps.
Economic Pressure
A pragmatic approach involves leveraging Afghanistan's deteriorating economy, which has contracted by 27% since 2020. Economic sanctions could pressure the Taliban to comply with human rights obligations. Yet this strategy risks worsening the humanitarian crisis and may therefore be untenable despite its potential effectiveness.
Conclusion
The Taliban's Laws on Vice and Virtue signal an alarming future for women in Afghanistan. Their disregard for international human rights standards has been evident since 2021, and the new laws risk becoming part of a wider system of persecution. Western states and international organisations must mobilise legal and political mechanisms to address violations, although current efforts have largely been ineffective. Without decisive action, the Taliban may succeed in entrenching their interpretation of Sharia, creating a dystopian reality for Afghan women.
Not sure how close you are to qualifying?
The path-fit quiz reads your situation and shows you which routes you are ready for, and exactly what to do next. Four minutes, no account needed to start.
Check your readiness