The State of Diversity in 2024
In honour of Black History Month 2024, it is essential to examine why the largest UK law firms continue to lack diversity at senior levels. Although many firms made public commitments to diversity and inclusion after 2020, the proportion of Black partners remains disproportionately low.
According to the Solicitors Regulation Authority, 3 per cent of lawyers are Black. Compared with the 4 per cent of Black people in the workforce, the gap is clear. The disparity becomes more pronounced at partnership level. Only 1 per cent of salaried partners are Black, and 3 per cent of full equity partners are Black. The largest firms have the lowest proportion of Black, Asian and minority ethnic partners.
One explanation is that Black lawyers tend to establish sole practices. However, the broader trend reflects systemic underrepresentation at senior levels within major firms.
The Post-2020 Push for Diversity
Following the murder of George Floyd and the global visibility of the Black Lives Matter movement, law firms introduced new diversity and inclusion initiatives. These included commitments to:
• encourage diversity at all levels of seniority • educate employees on racism and bias • create more inclusive working environments
Several firms set ambitious recruitment targets. Norton Rose Fulbright introduced a 25 per cent BAME trainee recruitment target. Linklaters set a target of 35 per cent ethnic minority trainees beginning in the 2020 to 2021 cycle.
Firms also set partnership targets. A and O Shearman committed to 15 per cent BAME partners in the UK by 2025. Clifford Chance aims for 15 per cent of UK and US partner promotions and lateral hires to come from minority ethnic backgrounds by 2025, a target it is currently exceeding.
Many firms have also introduced anti-racism workshops and educational programmes. Gatehouse Chambers even changed its name from Hardwicke Chambers to acknowledge Lord Hardwicke’s role in perpetuating slavery.
Despite these efforts, the underrepresentation of Black lawyers at senior levels remains largely unchanged four years later.
Why Does This Trend Persist
Research from People in Law shows that mid-ranking Black lawyers at the largest UK firms are four times more likely to leave than their peers. Poor retention is central to understanding the lack of diversity at partnership level. If Black lawyers leave due to racism, bias or hostile working environments, they cannot progress to senior roles.
The research also highlights two structural issues: poor-quality feedback and unfair work allocation.
Feedback
Progression requires regular, honest and constructive feedback. Without it, lawyers cannot develop the skills needed for senior roles. Firms must prioritise mentorship schemes and consistent one-to-one feedback meetings. These systems allow lawyers to raise concerns early, build trust with managers, and receive guidance that supports long-term development.
A continuous feedback culture is essential to retain Black lawyers and ensure equal access to professional growth.
Fair Work Allocation
Fair work allocation is critical for career progression. Black lawyers must have access to high-quality work, client exposure and business development opportunities. Partners are expected to bring clients into the firm. If Black lawyers are excluded from early networking opportunities, their client base will be smaller than their peers, making partnership less attainable.
Improving diversity at partnership level requires a comprehensive approach. Firms must ensure that all lawyers receive meaningful work opportunities from the start of their careers.
The Importance of Retention
Retention is the missing link in diversity strategies. Recruitment targets alone cannot solve the problem. Firms must create environments where Black lawyers feel valued, supported and able to thrive. This includes addressing unconscious bias, eliminating hostile behaviours and ensuring that Black lawyers are not disproportionately burdened by weaponised incompetence or unfair expectations.
Not sure how close you are to qualifying?
The path-fit quiz reads your situation and shows you which routes you are ready for, and exactly what to do next. Four minutes, no account needed to start.
Check your readiness