Introduction
The Financial Conduct Authority introduced a new Anti‑Greenwashing Rule on 31 May 2024. Outlets such as Bloomberg have described the regulation as one of the most far‑reaching anti‑greenwashing measures ever implemented, with significant consequences for the UK banking sector. This article outlines the rule, its purpose and its potential impact on financial institutions.
What Is Greenwashing?
Greenwashing refers to deceptive practices companies use to present themselves as more environmentally friendly than they are. In the financial sector, banks that pledge carbon neutrality while financing fossil fuel projects are frequently accused of greenwashing. This creates a misleading image that does not reflect actual practices.
Greenwashing harms consumers and distorts the market, especially as sustainability increasingly shapes consumer decisions. The Anti‑Greenwashing Rule aims to address the mismatch between what firms claim and what they do.
What Is the Anti‑Greenwashing Rule?
The FCA’s Anti‑Greenwashing Rule requires all environmental or sustainability‑related claims made by FCA‑authorised firms to be “fair, clear and not misleading”.
Under this rule, sustainability claims must be:
- honest
- transparent
- balanced
- fully substantiated
Firms cannot highlight positive aspects while ignoring negative impacts or caveats. Environmental claims must be supported by evidence such as data or statistics, and that evidence must not be manipulated. Any limitations must be disclosed.
The FCA may take “further action” if it believes a firm has misled consumers, intentionally or unintentionally. Actions may include orders to withdraw misleading materials, monetary fines or public identification under the FCA’s “name and shame” regime. This regime allows the FCA to disclose the names of firms under investigation before the investigation concludes, creating reputational risks for banks.
Why Did the FCA Introduce These Rules?
The regulation aligns with wider European trends. In January 2024, the European Parliament passed legislation banning companies from labelling products as “biodegradable” or “carbon neutral” without evidence.
The FCA’s rule has three main objectives:
1. Supporting Net Zero Goals
By holding firms accountable, the regulation encourages genuine sustainable practices and supports the UK’s net zero commitments.
2. Protecting Consumers and Smaller Firms
The rule aims to prevent larger firms from using misleading claims to overshadow smaller firms that genuinely pursue sustainable practices. As James Alexander of the UK Sustainable Investment and Finance Association notes, the rule “helps balance the playing field for those who have been doing the right thing”.
3. Increasing Market Confidence
If stakeholders can trust sustainability claims, market confidence will increase, potentially leading to greater investment in sustainable products.
Potential Impacts on Financial Institutions
The regulation has significant implications because of its wide scope, ambiguity, and increased litigation risk.
Wide Scope
Any material produced by a bank, including marketing materials, websites and bond prospectuses, may fall under FCA scrutiny. The FCA may argue that a claim is misleading if the “overall impression” created by a visual presentation contradicts actual practices. For example, a rainforest image on a bank’s website could be challenged if it creates an unjustified impression of environmental commitment.
Increased Investigations and Litigation
The rule provides a clear basis for challenging firms. Private individuals may also sue banks for compensation if misleading Environmental, Social and Governance claims influenced their decisions. This exposes banks to increased private litigation.
Climate activists have already urged the FCA to investigate Barclays, HSBC, Santander, NatWest and Lloyds. A letter to the FCA alleged that Santander’s financing of Liquefied Natural Gas and fracking projects contradicts its climate pledges. Although the FCA has not acted, the letter illustrates how banks may be affected.
What Should Banks Do?
Banks must review all environmental claims and materials to identify potential risks. They must ensure that sustainability claims are supported by up‑to‑date evidence.
Given the regulation’s breadth, Baker McKenzie advises banks to adopt a holistic approach. This means assessing not only factual accuracy but also the “overall impression” created by materials, including imagery.
Banks must therefore move beyond fact-checking and consider how consumers and regulators may interpret their sustainability messaging.
Conclusion
The Anti‑Greenwashing Rule is necessary as society’s interest in ESG matters grows. Even banks criticised by activists, such as Santander, have welcomed the regulation. However, its unprecedented scope means that banks and legal advisers must take proactive steps to mitigate litigation and regulatory risk.
Not sure how close you are to qualifying?
The path-fit quiz reads your situation and shows you which routes you are ready for, and exactly what to do next. Four minutes, no account needed to start.
Check your readiness