Introduction
The European Union's "Chat Control" legislation refers to a proposed regulation first introduced in 2022 aimed at preventing and combating child sexual abuse online. As of July 2024, the proposal has failed to pass in the Council of the European Union for the fourth time and still faces significant opposition from civil society organisations, digital rights groups, and several Member States.
This article outlines the regulation's context, purpose, and proposed mechanisms, and explains why it has become one of the most controversial digital policy proposals in recent EU history.
Context and Purpose
The proposal seeks to establish a uniform and transparent legal framework for preventing and addressing child sexual abuse and grooming online. It aims to balance the rights of children, digital users and internet service providers by giving providers legal certainty regarding their obligations to assess and mitigate risks. It also seeks to empower providers to detect, report and remove child sexual abuse material in a manner consistent with the fundamental rights protected under the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights.
The proposal forms part of the EU's 2020 Strategy for a More Effective Fight Against Child Sexual Abuse and its 2021 Strategy for the Rights of the Child. These initiatives were influenced by a survey conducted by The Economist, which found that half of the children surveyed had experienced sexual abuse online.
The proposal's legal basis rests on the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child and Article 24(2) of the EU Charter, which requires that children's best interests be a primary consideration. The proposal also cites Article 114 TFEU to support its internal market rationale.
Proposed Measures and Reasoning
The regulation would require the bulk scanning of digital communications, including encrypted messages, for indicators of child sexual abuse. Messages, photographs and links would be scanned, and service providers such as Telegram, Signal and WhatsApp would be required to install "vetting technology". Personal cloud storage services, including Apple iCloud and Google Drive, would also fall within the regulation's scope.
Key measures include:
- mandatory scanning of communications for child sexual abuse material
- stringent age verification for websites hosting potentially harmful content
- reporting obligations to the EU Centre
- removal or blocking of content upon request
- potential use of artificial intelligence and machine learning to detect child sexual abuse material
Impact assessments conducted by the European Commission argued that voluntary measures by service providers had been insufficient. National legislation was said to have caused fragmentation and inefficiency, prompting calls for a harmonised EU‑wide approach.
Government Positions
As of July 2024, the following Member States supported the proposal:
Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, Denmark, Finland, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Portugal, Romania, Slovakia, Spain and Sweden.
Germany and Poland opposed the proposal.
Estonia, the Netherlands, Slovenia, the Czech Republic and Austria abstained.
Concerns and Criticisms
Opposition to the proposal has been extensive. Critics argue that the regulation amounts to mass surveillance and infringes fundamental rights under the EU Charter.
Privacy and Data Security
The proposal requires users to allow vetting technology to scan their communications. Critics argue that encrypted data would be compromised, creating significant privacy risks. Strict age-verification requirements may also prevent teenagers and young adults from accessing messaging apps, a concern some commentators describe as "digital house arrest".
There is also concern about the lack of transparency around the artificial intelligence and machine learning systems used to scan communications.
Civil Society and International Organisations
Even organisations dedicated to preventing child sexual abuse have criticised the proposal. Germany's Federal Child Protection Association described it as "ineffective and disproportionate". The United Nations and UNICEF have warned that weakening encryption threatens privacy, self‑expression, and security, and increases risks such as identity theft.
The proposal also raises concerns for professions requiring secure communication, including lawyers and journalists.
Political Opposition
Patrick Breyer, a Member of the European Parliament, has been one of the strongest critics. He argues that the proposal breaches civil liberties and encourages citizens to oppose it. Breyer and other critics advocate alternative approaches, including:
- increased funding for organisations combating child sexual abuse
- awareness campaigns
- digital literacy education for adolescents
- addressing root causes rather than scanning private communications
Legal Implications
Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights protects the right to respect for private and family life, including correspondence. Critics argue the proposal conflicts with this right. Article 10, which protects freedom of expression, may also be threatened.
In Podchasov v Russia (2024), the European Court of Human Rights held that weakening encryption can lead to indiscriminate monitoring of communications, violating the right to private life and freedom of expression. The proposed regulation appears inconsistent with this precedent, raising questions about its legal viability.
Further Developments
As of June 2024, amendments have been proposed to shift the focus toward digital safety rather than restricting access. Under these amendments:
- scanning would occur only with user consent
- professional accounts belonging to military, police and intelligence personnel would be exempt
However, critics argue that these changes do not sufficiently protect privacy. They warn that passing the regulation could pave the way for further legislation expanding law enforcement access to user data. High‑Level Group meetings scheduled for 2024 aim to examine obstacles law enforcement faces in accessing digital data, raising concerns about future regulatory trends.
The Council and Parliament are expected to consider the proposal again in October and December 2024.
Not sure how close you are to qualifying?
The path-fit quiz reads your situation and shows you which routes you are ready for, and exactly what to do next. Four minutes, no account needed to start.
Check your readiness