Punishment and its purpose
Across history, punishment has been central to legal systems. In England and Wales, criminal sanctions aim to deter wrongdoing and reinforce public confidence. But this logic collapses when an innocent person is punished for a crime they did not commit.
When innocence is ignored
The case of Archie Williams, who served 37 years in the United States for a rape he did not commit, shocked millions. Although American law does not apply in the UK, his story resonates because similar injustices have occurred here.
Miscarriages of justice in England and Wales stretch back centuries. In 1660, John, Richard and Joan Perry were executed for the murder of William Harrison, only for Harrison to reappear alive. In 1949, George Kelly was executed for a double murder he did not commit. In 1950, Timothy Evans was executed for the murder of his wife, later proven innocent. These cases expose the irreversible consequences of evidential error and misdirection of law.
Modern miscarriages of justice
Wrongful convictions continue into the 21st century. Sean Hodgson served 30 years for the murder of Teresa De Simone before DNA evidence overturned his conviction in 2009. He received £250,000 in compensation, a sum that cannot restore decades lost.
Ched Evans, a professional footballer, was convicted of rape before being acquitted on appeal. The Oval Four; Winston Trew, Sterling Christie, George Griffiths and Constantine Boucher, had their convictions quashed after 47 years. These cases demonstrate that wrongful convictions are not rare exceptions but recurring failures.
The role of the Criminal Cases Review Commission
Section 8 of the Criminal Appeal Act 1995 established the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) to investigate suspected miscarriages of justice in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. The CCRC acts as a safeguard for those who have exhausted conventional appeal routes.
Since 1997, the CCRC has referred 692 cases to the Court of Appeal. These represent only the cases that meet its criteria and only the individuals who had the strength to challenge their convictions. Many others remain unheard.
The human impact
The phrase “Only bad people go to prison” is a comforting illusion. While most prisoners have committed offences, a significant minority have not. Some plead guilty because they feel they have no choice. Others suffer from mental illness and are imprisoned instead of receiving appropriate treatment.
Victims of miscarriages of justice lose employment, relationships and stability. Compensation is inconsistent and often inadequate. Even when released, many struggle to find work, with only one‑third securing employment. Others become homeless or rely on shelters. Freedom does not restore the life they once had. The world moves forward, but it does not wait for them.
Preventing future injustice
There is no perfect solution. Preventing miscarriages of justice requires coordinated action across the criminal justice system. Education in modern investigative methods, cooperation between prosecution and defence, accurate application of law and clear judicial directions are essential.
If injustice exists even in a small fraction of cases, confidence in the system is undermined. Ensuring that miscarriages of justice are prevented is vital for public trust and for the legitimacy of the legal system itself.
Not sure how close you are to qualifying?
The path-fit quiz reads your situation and shows you which routes you are ready for, and exactly what to do next. Four minutes, no account needed to start.
Check your readiness